Can addiction be ‘forgotten’?

In an article in the New Scientist magazine, published 21st April 2012, it was said that addicts can be taught to forget their addiction. The article states that exposing people to drug-related cues without actually supplying the drug can reduce the addiction, but only if the memory of addiction in the addict is retrieved first.

The study, conducted by Yan-Xue Xue et al. (2012), was first carried out with rats as participants in eight experiments. The study was then conducted on recovering heroin addicts who were in-patients. The first day of the study consisted of baseline measurements of craving for heroin using VAS (visual analogue scale), on which participants rated their craving on a scale of 1 to 10. On day two, the addicts were assigned to one of three groups: no memory retrieval and extinction (group 1), memory retrieval and 10 minute delay and extinction (group 2), or memory retrieval and 6-hour delay and extinction (group 3). Heart rate and blood pressure were measured in all participants before and after cue exposures to provide additional measures of reaction to cues. During the memory retrieval, participants were shown a 5-minute video of the use of heroin. During the extinction sessions, participants were exposed to three heroin-related cues, or drug paraphernalia, in four sessions. These two stages occurred over two consecutive days. After the extinction sessions, participants were asked to rate their level of craving for heroin, and heart rate and blood pressure were measured. Craving levels were measured again on days 4, 34 and 184 using VAS.

The study found that the method was effective in reducing cue-induced cravings for heroin, but only for participants in group 2. This suggests that extinction methods can be successful in reducing cravings in recovering addicts if the time window after memory retrieval is short. The effects were also found to be lasting.

This study can be generalised to a population of recovering male heroin-addicts, as the sample used was representative of many drug users and was conducted within a treatment centre for drug users. However, as the study was conducted in China, the overall ability to generalise may be slightly limited as there may be cultural differences. Reliability could be said to be slightly lacking because of the use of VAS, as participants may have lied about their levels of craving. However, this was controlled for by the use of objective measurements of heart rate and blood pressure, so reliability is not greatly affected.

The results do not provide evidence that this works for all addictions as only heroin addicts were studied, so this could provide the basis for future research into non-pharmacological treatments for addiction. The sample also only consisted of recovering addicts who had not taken opiates for at least one month, and other drugs for at least six months. This also provides another basis for future research as it would be interesting to find out if the treatment works for current addicts, not just former users.

In conclusion, this research provides strong evidence that heroin addiction in recovering drug users can actually be ‘forgotten’ and has high levels of reliability making it quite trustworthy. The sample allows some generalisability, although populations not included could be studied in future research. Overall, the study provided useful information, and the use of such treatment could reduce the number of drug users in society, which may have a positive effect on crime levels, as crimes are often committed under the influence of drugs.

 

References:

New Scientist. (2012, 21 April). Addicts taught to ‘forget’ addiction. New Scientist, 214(2861), 17.

Xue, Y-X., Luo, Y-X, Wu, P., Shi, H-S., Xue, L-F., Chen, C., . . . Lu, L. (2012). A memory retrieval-extinction procedure to prevent drug craving and relapse.  Science, 336, 241-245. doi: 10.1126/science.1215070

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Can being in a small class in school increase your income?

Recent research into the long-term effects of class size in schools by Fredriksson, Öckert and Oosterbeek (2012) has shown that the smaller the class size, the higher the ability of the children. It was also found that people in a small class go on to earn more later on in life.

Previous research into the short-term effects of class size show that children learn more in a small class. This may be because teachers are able to spend more time with individual children in lessons to help them with specific areas they find difficult. However, the samples used in this research are primarily American children, which mean that generalisability may be affected.

Research conducted by the IFAU (Institute for Evaluation of Labour Market and Education Policy) in 2012 in Sweden studied the short- and long-term effects of class size (Expertanswer (Expertsvar in Swedish), 2012). The sample consisted of nearly 31,000 students from four different cohorts; children born in 1967, 1972, 1977 and 1982. Questionnaires were given to the children in 6th grade, and asked questions about their own perception of their self-confidence, endurance and expectations. The study looked at non-cognitive and cognitive skills from the combination of the results from the questionnaires and the achieved results in tests during 6th grade and 9th grade. The educational attainment and income as adults (aged 27-42) from the sample were also explored.

The results show that students in a small class size from grades four to six had better cognitive and non-cognitive skills than students in larger classes. They also achieved higher scores in national tests in grades six and nine, and stated higher levels of self-confidence and endurance in the questionnaires. It was also found that they earned more money than students in a larger class later on in life, increasing by 3% for a reduction in class size of five students.

However, this research does have issues. The use of questionnaires in the methodology may produce subjective results, which may lead to less reliability from demand characteristics or social desirability bias. This effect may not occur significantly though because the questionnaires were conducted by children, who are often honest in their answers. Another issue is that the data collected for students in grade nine was only collected for males, as the researchers were unable to obtain the data for females (Fredriksson, Öckert & Oosterbeek, 2012). This means that the results cannot be fully generalised to females because there is no supporting data. Subject attrition also occurred, but only for 1% of the sample, which would not have had much of an impact of the results. The sample selected may not be representative of modern society as the cohorts selected may have experienced teaching in a very different way to children growing up now.

Although the conclusion reached suggests that small class sizes are beneficial in a child’s education, it has been suggested by Dr Ioan Rees, Chartered Psychologist and Managing Director of Sycol, that a small class size will not help children with poor tuition. He also states that small classes can help good teachers to become even better teachers, but the argument that small classes are beneficial is questionable (BPS, 2012).

In conclusion, research into the effects of class size are highly useful, showing that small class sizes are beneficial towards educational attainment, highlighting improvements that could be made to the educational system. However, such research can have flaws, such as a lack of reliability from the use of questionnaires, and a lack of generalisability when some data cannot be obtained. Overall though, the usefulness could be seen to outweigh the issues, but other factors should be studied first.

References

http://www.bps.org.uk/news/children-do-better-smaller-classes

Expertanswer (Expertsvar in Swedish) (2012, March 6). Smaller school classes leads to better student outcomes and higher wages. ScienceDaily. Retrieved March 21, 2012, from http://www.sciencedaily.com­ /releases/2012/03/120306131150.htm

Fredriksson, P., Öckert, B. & Oosterbeek, H. (2012). Long-term effects of class size. (Working Paper 2012:5). Retrieved from the Institute for Evaluation of Labour Market and Education Policy website: http://www.ifau.se/en/Research/Publications/Working-papers/2012/Long-term-effects-of-class-size/

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Jury Decision Making

Research into the way in which jurors and juries make decisions during trials in court is highly important within both psychology and law. However, many difficulties arise when conducting this research. Due to jurors being sworn to secrecy about the case they are involved in, mock trials take place in research. This leads to assumptions being made about stages of decision making as we cannot enter the jury room during a real trial, reducing the reliability and ecological validity of such research.

Hastie et al. (1983) described the stages of decision making that take place amongst members of a jury. Perhaps the stages described don’t occur within a real jury, as the pressure of being locked in a room until a decision is made may be greater in a real jury than a jury for a mock trial. However, we can neither prove nor disprove that these stages take place, although it seems highly likely that they do.

Research has shown that the type of evidence presented can have a massive impact on the decisions that jurors make about the verdict of the defendant. Again though, this research is conducted with mock jurors, reducing the reliability and ecological validity. For example, gruesome evidence has been shown to increase the likelihood of a guilty verdict being given (Bright & Goodman-Delahunty, 2006). This is probably due to higher levels of anger and emotion in mock jurors who saw the gruesome evidence compared to jurors who did not see the evidence.

The order in which evidence is given has also been shown to have an effect upon the verdict given by the jury (Pennington & Hastie, 1988). It was found that evidence presented in story order, rather than in witness order, has a greater impact and this is more so when the evidence is from the prosecution. This research has some ecological validity because the case presented was adapted from a real-life case. However, participants were paid to take part and were university students, so the results cannot be generalised to a real jury, as it would be made up of a variety of different people and real jurors do not get paid for their service.

Overall though, research into decision making within a jury is highly important. Although studies often lack reliability, ecological validity and the ability to be generalised, they can highlight important issues in which the way evidence is presented affects the decision made, and also the stages jurors go through to reach their verdict, making them very useful. The usefulness of these studies, I believe, is more important than the levels of ecological validity and reliability. This is because highlighting these influences can lead to important changes that are needed in order to make trials fair for defendants and allow a reasonable verdict to be reached from the appropriate evidence. If changes were not made, a person’s life may be negatively affected by the verdict reached, whether this is the defendant or victim, as the wrong verdict may be reached.

References:

Bright, D. A., & Goodman-Delahunty, J. (2006). Gruesome evidence and emotion: Anger, blame and jury decision-making. Law and Human Behaviour, 30, 183-202. doi: 10.1007/s10979-006-9027-y

Hastie, R., Penrod, S. D., & Pennington, N. (1983). Inside the Jury. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.

Pennington, N., & Hastie, R. (1988) Explanation-based decision making: Effects of memory structure on judgment. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 14, 521-533. doi: 10.1037/0278-7393.14.3.521

Posted in Uncategorized | 7 Comments

Is shyness a mental illness?

On Monday (13/02/12), the BPS posted an article on their website asking whether shyness should be considered a mental illness (http://www.bps.org.uk/news/dsm-5-shyness-mental-illness). As well as shyness, the DSM-5 is now proposing that eccentric behaviour, gambling, internet addiction and even bereavement could be classed as mental disorders. This could result in millions more people becoming diagnosed with a disorder. Is it really right to consider these common traits to be mental disorders?

Many people with these traits are suddenly going to be labelled as having a mental disorder and this is not right. If these traits are classified as mental disorders, it means that unnecessary treatments may be suggested. Treatment for bereavement is not needed as it’s a natural process that people go through. The use of the DSM for diagnosis of these ‘mental disorders’ may often result in the use of medication for treatment. In 2008, the BBC posted an article on their website about shyness, and stated that some pharmaceutical companies supply anti-depressant drugs to people considered to be shy (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/magazine/7274825.stm). Surely there are better ways to reduce shyness than using drugs. Cognitive-Behavioural Therapy is a suitable way to reduce shyness and therefore, medication should only be used if the therapy doesn’t help. Often though, therapy is enough as it helps to change thinking patterns that result from being shy and so can reduce the symptoms experienced by an individual.

With the DSM-5 now containing more mental disorders than ever before, can we really consider it to be a valid way of diagnosing people? New mental disorders mean that most people will eventually be labelled with a mental disorder and this shouldn’t be the case. The DSM-5’s proposed changes may seem valid to some people as many of these traits could be reduced by using psychological treatment. However, some traits, such as shyness and eccentric behaviour, are part of the personality of an individual, and they should not be forced to change just because they don’t fit in with the stereotypical ‘normal’ person.

Another problem with the proposed changes by the DSM-5 is that the DSM describes the symptoms of a disorder, but many people experience different and sometimes unique symptoms and so it is hard to create accurate and reliable prototypes that the DSM should have. For example, shyness may be experienced differently in certain people and so how can an accurate prototype be developed?

The proposed changes may make the DSM-5 more reliable than previous editions because a more accurate list of symptoms can be developed separating previously listed disorders into component parts. This means that in the long run, a more accurate diagnosis of an individual could be made and these diagnoses would be the same around the world for all users of the DSM-5.

In conclusion, I believe that shyness and other common traits should not be classified as mental disorders, as often these traits are part of the personality of an individual. The proposed changes to the DSM-5 could increase the reliability of diagnosis but it results in a lack of validity, which may be just as important. Although some traits could require treatment, psychological treatment should be sought first with medication being a last resort, although this could be described in the DSM-5.

Posted in Uncategorized | 10 Comments

Bystander Effect – The Murder of Kitty Genovese

The bystander effect states that the greater the number of people present in a social environment, the less likely people will help a person in need.

The bystander effect was shown in the case of the murder of Kitty Genovese in 1964. Kitty was returning home from her day at work, but was attacked outside her apartment building at 3:20 am. Despite the people in the nearby apartment block hearing her calls for help, no-one responded or even called the police. Thirty-eight people witnessed the attack and didn’t intervene. Thirty minutes passed before the police were called.

This case shows one part of the bystander effect: diffusion of responsibility. This is when people don’t feel the pressure to act because they believe the responsibility to help lies within the whole group.

There are many studies on the bystander effect. For example, Darley and Latané (1968) conducted an experiment on bystander intervention in an emergency.  In this study, participants (college students) were told that they would be talking to other college students about their experiences in college, and that the experimenter would not be listening whilst they were doing this. Participants were lead to believe that they were either in a group of 2, 3 or 6, when they were actually alone. This was done using pre-recorded voices of a ‘victim’ and confederates. After each group member had had their turn to talk, the participant heard the ‘victim’ having a seizure. The time taken for participants to report the seizure was recorded. As expected, the larger the group the participants believed they were in, the longer it took for them to report the seizure. However, not all participants reported the seizure during or after it.

This study by Darley and Latané (1968) highlights the effects of the diffusion of responsibility but does have methodological flaws. Ecological validity is lacking because the study didn’t take place in a real-life situation. However, participants believed that it was real, so it could be seen as slightly representative of real-life. The ability to generalise results has been limited because of the relatively small sample size (72 participants) and only consisted of college students, so may only be representative of a few specific personality types. Also, the ethical guideline of deception was broken, but no harm was caused to any participants and they were fully debriefed. It can be argued that deception has to be broken in research studying bystander effects because otherwise demand characteristics or social desirability bias may occur and results would be invalid and unreliable.

More research has been conducted in order to study the bystander effect, such as a study by Chekroun and Brauer (2002) which didn’t involve an emergency situation, but rather negative social behaviour and differing levels of personal implication of these. It was found that social control occurred in the situations where lower personal implication was discovered, with this being graffiti in an elevator. Again, deception was used but there is no other way to conduct research in this area.

In conclusion, the bystander effect, particularly diffusion of responsibility, can have a massive impact on social events and I believe that it is important to study these effects to understand why and how people behave in an emergency situation within a social environment. Some studies may lack ecological validity, but it is possible to conduct studies that are representative of real-life, such as Piliavin, Rodin and Piliavin (1969). Also, studies into the bystander effect use deception, which may be seen as unethical, but it is used in such a way that doesn’t cause harm to participants and maximises reliability.

References:

Chekroun, P. & Brauer, M. (2002). The bystander effect and social control behaviour: the effect of the presence of others on people’s reactions to norm violations. European Journal of Social Psychology, 32, 853-867.

Darley, J. M. & Latané, B. (1968). Bystander intervention in emergencies: diffusion of responsibility. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 8, 377-383.

Piliavin, I. M., Rodin, J. A. & Piliavin, J. (1969). Good samaritanism: An underground phenomenon? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 13, 289-299.

Posted in Uncategorized | 6 Comments

Sex: Gender differences in colour preference

Journal Article

The journal article ‘Biological components of sex differences in colour preference’ explains research on why males prefer the colour blue and females prefer the colour pink. However, the title of this journal article is inaccurate in terms of both the study design and the findings presented. The study design doesn’t actually measure biological factors that may affect colour preference between gender; instead it focuses on visual preference of hue. This is surely more a colour processing preference, rather than a biological factor and depends upon cognitive processing of visual stimuli. Biology plays little or no part in this at all.

                The findings presented are explained in terms of an evolutionary theory, which does explain biological factors, but there is no evidence in the findings that the differences in colour preference were due to evolution. It is stated that females prefer ‘reddish-purple’ colours due to their roles as gatherers, when they had to search for red leaves among green foliage. However, the study doesn’t really focus on finding an explanation for gender differences in colour preference; instead the researchers try to see if there is a difference. The researchers also develop another explanation, but this describes how nationality and culture affects colour preference, stating the reason for the Chinese population preferring a ‘reddish’ contrast just because red is their national colour of good luck. If the researchers believe that this is a reason for colour preference, the title should not refer to only biological factors affecting preference.

                Also, the title suggests that there is a great difference in colour preference between genders, but the findings suggest that, universally, males and females prefer a ‘bluish’ contrast, showing little sex difference at all, and therefore, the title is slightly misleading.

                The explanation of the findings is not necessarily justified because the researchers explain why different colour preferences occur between genders, when actually, the preferences weren’t too different, particularly within the Chinese population studied.

News Report

The news report published by The Times newspaper describing the research conducted jumps to the conclusion that the colour preference between genders found in the study was particularly significant and the headline for the article supports this. The headline states ‘At last, science discovers why blue is for boys but girls really do prefer pink’. This headline is completely misleading because the newspaper and journal articles both guess the reasoning behind the preferences; no explanation was actually developed as a result of the findings of the research.

                This conclusion that the news report comes to is not warranted by the research conducted because there was no significant difference in colour preference. Instead, it was found that females and males prefer the same ‘bluish’ contrast, but females slightly tend towards the redder/pinker side. The article also mainly focuses on the evolutionary explanation of sex differences in colour preference, but there is no evidence from the study that this is actually true; it is just a speculation by the researchers and the journalists.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Are all BPS guidelines as important as each other?

The British Psychological Society (BPS) formed in 1901 and represents psychology within the UK. They have a code of conduct by which psychologists must abide, and this code of conduct is based upon four main principles: respect, competence, responsibility and integrity.

The ethical principle of respect states that informed consent must be gained from all participants and enough information must be given to participants in order for them to give full consent. It also states that all data collected must be kept confidential and this is maintained by the Data Protection Act 1998. Also, all participants should be made aware that they have the right to withdraw from research at any time without penalty.

The ethical principle of competence states that ethical decisions should be made in order to maintain high levels of competence within professional research, including resolving dilemmas that may arise.

The ethical principle of responsibility states that all participants must be debriefed to a suitable level at the end of a piece of research but without making evaluative statements about a participant. Also, protection of participants is a main priority in this principle and any risks to participants that may arise should be considered carefully. Participants should be made aware of any possible risks.

The ethical principle of integrity states that deception shouldn’t occur and plagiarism should be avoided at all costs. Also, personal relationships between the researcher and a participants should be avoided in order to maintain objectivity.

 Often, some of these guidelines are breached within research, particularly when participants are deceived. It may be said then, that deception isn’t as important as some of the other guidelines.

For example, a study by Piliavin et al. (1969) consisted of deceiving passengers on the subway in America. The study looked at whether help would be given to a needy person by other passengers if another person helped first, but the time it took for a researcher to intervene was manipulated as one of the independent variables. Passengers did not know that research was being carried out in their carriage and were not aware that the people needing help were only actors. Deception was used within this study because demand characteristics may have occurred if passengers had known and the aim of the research could have been guessed. This would have affected the results.

The protection of participants, I believe, is a very important guideline to uphold. For example, in a well known study by Milgram (1963), some participants experienced negative effects from participating in the research. During the study, many participants experienced nervousness and sweating as a result of the pressure placed on them. However, three participants experienced seizures as a result of participating and one of these seizures was so bad, the study was put on hold. It may be said that the participants were protected and no long term harm was done because all participants were followed up after one year. However, having seizures occurring during research is not protecting participants.

Some guidelines are more important than others because they protect the participants from any harm, whether that be physically, mentally or through indirect ways. Guidelines such as deception are less important that gaining informed consent and keeping data confidential, as well as giving participants the right to withdraw from research. This is because without deception, the results of many pieces of research would be affected by demand characteristics and social desirability as participants would know too much about the research and may play up to the aims or hypotheses.

 

References:

Milgram, S. (1963). Behavioural study of obedience. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 67, 371-378.

Piliavin, I. M., Rodin, J. A. & Piliavin, J. (1969). Good samaritanism: An underground phenomenon? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 13, 289-299.

Posted in Uncategorized | 5 Comments

Independent Measures versus Repeated Measures; is it possible to decide which is best?

Independent measures is when there are separate groups of participants for each condition in a piece of research. There are many benefits but also many downfalls to using independent measures as an experimental design within a study. An advantage of independent measures is that there are no practice or order effects as participants are only subjected to one condition. This eliminates the chance of participants learning the order of any tests and also prevents fatigue from setting in. Another strength of the design is that fewer materials are needed as they can be used with different people in other conditions, reducing the cost and also time collecting materials. Also, demand characteristics will be less likely to occur because the participants will be less likely to be able to guess the aim of the research. A disadvantage to the independent measures design is that more participants are needed to conduct the research which often increases the cost and also the time needed to conduct the study. Also, individual differences are more likely to play a part and may negatively affect the results.

Repeated measures is when the same group of participants is subjected to each condition in a piece of research. Again, there are many benefits to a repeated measure design and also costs. Unlike independent measures, individual differences are unlikely to have an effect on the results collected in research because the same group of people is used in each condition. Also, repeated measures is more time and cost effective because participants are used in more than one condition. However, the downfalls of repeated measures are the benefits of independent measures. Order effects are more likely to occur because participants will have had the opportunity to learn the tests that may be used. Also, demand characteristics are likely to occur because more time to guess the aim of research has been given to participants.

Samuel and Bryant (1984) conducted a study that consisted of both an independent and repeated measures design. Independent measures was used so that different age groups of children could participate within the research. Repeated measures was used because the children in each age group participated in three different conditions across three types of task. The benefits of using independent measures in this research allows a comparison between the abilities of children of different age groups, but the disadvantages of this are that more participants were needed. The advantages of using a repeated measures design within this research are that individual differences could not play a part across the conditions as the same children took part, allowing an accurate measure of the ability of children across age groups.

Overall, I think it is difficult and almost impossible to say which experimental design is best because the disadvantages of one design are the advantages of the other. I think the best design depends on the type of research being conducted and so the decision should be left to the researcher. However, when used within conjunction with each other, like in the study by Samuel and Bryant (1984), they can be equally as advantageous.

References

Samuel, J. & Bryant, P. (1984). Asking only one question in the conservation experiment. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 25 (2), 315-318. doi: 10.1111/j. 1469-7610.1984.tb00152.x

Posted in Uncategorized | 3 Comments

Why are laboratory experiments so important in psychology?

Laboratory experiments play a major role in psychological research. They allow us to find a cause and effect relationship between variables that would not be possible with many other research methods.

Laboratory experiments use different conditions to measure the effects of increasing the manipulation of the independent variable. The variable that is measured is called the dependent variable. Often, laboratory experiments consist of two conditions; the experimental condition and the control condition. In the experimental condition, the independent variable is manipulated, whereas in the control condition, it is not. This allows us to see how the independent variable affects the dependent variable and we can therefore see a direct cause and effect relationship.

Laboratory experiments also allow for tight controls which prevent any extraneous variables from affecting the results, as these could possibly affect the results. If extraneous variables were not controlled for, the reliability of the results gained would be reduced as the same or similar results would not be collected if the research was repeated. In general, because of the controls put in place, the level of reliability is relatively high for laboratory experiments.

Laboratory experiments also produce quantitative data. This means that analysis of the results is more objective as fewer subjective interpretations can be made. However, this data does not provide an explanation as to why the results occurred but do allow us to see a relationship and find any anomalies.

Laboratory experiments do lack ecological validity. If ecological validity is present, a method is representative of a real-life situation. Laboratory experiments lack this because the environment is artificial. This means that participants may not behave in the same way as they would in a real-life situation and so the results become less valid. An example of this would be Loftus and Palmer (1974). In the study, participants were asked to watch clips of traffic accidents then answer questions from a questionnaire. They were asked to estimate the speed of the cars in the collision by a critical question that had a verb changed to make leading questions. It could be said that ecological validity is lacking from this piece of research because participants watched clips of collisions and so their levels of adrenalin would not have been massively increased and so they wouldn’t have experienced the same biological and emotional reaction as they would in real-life. This is machine reductionism.

In conclusion, I believe that laboratory experiments are possibly the most important pieces of research in psychology due to the chance to see a direct cause and effect relationship and also reduce the effects of extraneous variables. They allow for high reliability and collect objective data. However, the lack of ecological validity does reduce the usefulness but I think it is more important to have reliability and show relationships between variables rather than be representative of a real-life situation.

Georgi

 

Loftus, E. F. & Palmer, J. C. (1974) Reconstruction of automobile destruction: An example of the interaction between language and memory. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behaviour, 5, 585-589.

Posted in Uncategorized | 9 Comments

Are longitudinal studies worth carrying out?

A longitudinal study is one that takes place over a long period of time, measuring patterns of change and development. Longitudinal studies are often highly useful pieces of research in psychology.

Longitudinal studies are often used within the developmental approach of psychology where change is studied over time to see how behaviours and intellectual abilities develop. Kohlberg (1963) conducted a longitudinal study into moral development in children using 58 boys from Chicago as participants. The boys were aged 7, 10, 13 and 16. The boys were given a 2-hour interview in which they had ten dilemmas to solve, including the Heinz dilemma). Some of the boys from the study were interviewed up to age 30-36 at 3-yearly intervals to monitor progression through the stages of moral development. Kohlberg later conducted this study in the UK, Mexico, Taiwan, Turkey, the USA and Yucatan. Kohlberg found that there was development through the stages of moral development but it was slower in non-industrialised societies. Without conducting a longitudinal study, Kohlberg would not have been able to observe the development made, which has been shown to explain criminality.

Longitudinal studies can cause problems however. Subject attrition (where participants drop out of a study) is more likely to occur within these studies, particularly if the study began when participants were children and continues into adulthood. This can have a significant impact on the research as the participants may no longer be representative of the target population. Longitudinal studies are also more likely to suffer from experimenter bias and other subjectivities. This is because the experimenter is more likely to have grown closer to and developed a relationship with the participants. Also, because of the length of time needed to conduct such a study, they are incredibly expensive to run.

In conclusion, I do believe that longitudinal studies are well worth conducting because it allows for us to see behavioural and intellectual development over time giving us a greater understanding of developmental psychology. However, they are incredibly expensive to carry out and are more likely to suffer from factors that may affect the overall results and conclusions.

Georgi

Posted in Uncategorized | 5 Comments